I have found a few resources to use to help me in preparing worthwhile questions.
1. At the Ontario Ministry of Education, there is an excellent article entitled, "Asking Effective Questions." In the article there are eight tips for asking effective questions. But then there are many, many questions or question stems providing an amazing framework for asking good questions.
2. I also ran across this book by Schuster and Anderson. The book is set up by strands in math.
Even though I teach algebra, I find this book useful in developing questions to help my ninth graders make sense of the prerequisite math that they still struggle with. The questions are open-ended and challenging. For example: "Carla and Fiona are having a mathematical debate about the equation y = 1/2 x + 3. Carla thinks that every time y changes by one, x changes by 2. Fiona thinks that every time y changes by one-half, x changes by one. What do you think?"3. One other book I ran across provides ideas for differentiating. It is also organized in strands.
For each topic, the authors, Small and Lin, provide ideas for open questions and 2 parallel questions at different levels. One example that caught my eye is: "Another function is a lot like the given function. What might it be? Option 1: y = 3x^2 + 4 Option 2: y = 3^x. Follow up questions are provided: What happens to your function when x gets big? When x is quite small? What kinds of things might you change but still have a similar function? What would you choose not to change?I'm on the prowl for other great resources for developing strong questioning skills. Send me a note if you know of others!
A few tips I can give from my experiences:
ReplyDelete1. Sometimes I start by giving the students the answer. That way when we're talking about the process for finding the answer, they aren't hung up wondering whether they're correct or not. Also it demonstrates that I care about more than getting the right answer.
2. This may only apply to younger students, or perhaps students where English isn't their first language, but I was surprised to find out how difficult it was for students to grasp "missing information" questions, the kind that end with, "What information is needed in order to..." It amazed me that until we had talked explicitly about this question type several times, my students (4th graders) completely ignored the part asking about missing information. They jumped right to the question that the missing information would help answer without grasping that it was not currently possible to find the answer. It goes to show how much understanding language is wrapped up in understanding math.
3. I like providing students situations with lots of information and asking them to pose questions. Not only does it help them connect with math concepts in a different way, but it also helps them see that you can ask a lot of questions about one set of data or one situation. Sometimes students come up with questions you wouldn't even think to ask yourself.
4. Ask, "Are you sure?" even if they're right! Students are pretty smart. They realize that adults often ask this question to indicate that the student has made a mistake. Why not ask it even if you know they're correct? If you want a student to be confident in their answer, this is a question they should learn to ask themselves.
[...] I read a post called Questions and more questions! on the blog in stillness the [...]
ReplyDeleteThanks! I really liked the post from the Ontario Ministry and think the questions would make a great anchor chart for my 6th grade classroom
ReplyDelete